FLORIDARenovation Guide

Renovation Guides

Shingle, Metal or Tile? The Best Roofing Materials for Florida Homes

How architectural shingles, metal and concrete or clay tile compare for Florida homes on cost, hurricane performance, heat, weight, insurance and HOA rules.

Last updated: 2 min readBy the Florida Renovation Guide editorial teamTopic: Exterior Home Improvements

The short answer

  • Architectural shingles cost the least upfront, about $4.50–$8 per sq. ft. installed in Florida, by our planning estimates, and are the most common reroof.
  • Metal, about $7–$20 per sq. ft., and tile, about $9–$21, cost more but generally last longer when installed and maintained well.
  • Every option can meet Florida's wind code when it's an approved product installed to its approval. Installation quality matters as much as the material.
  • Tile is heavy. Switching from shingles to tile can require an engineer's review of the roof framing.
On this page

Choosing a roof in Florida means balancing upfront cost, how long you'll stay in the home, insurance, HOA rules and what your roof structure can carry. Here's how the main options compare.

The quick comparison

Architectural shinglesMetalConcrete or clay tile
Estimated installed cost (per sq. ft., Florida planning range)About $4.50–$8; impact-rated $6–$11About $7–$14 exposed-fastener, $10–$20 standing seamAbout $9–$16 concrete, $12–$21 clay
WeightLightLightestHeavy
LookFamiliar, many colorsModern or coastal, panels or shinglesClassic Florida and Mediterranean
MaintenanceInspect after storms; replace damaged shinglesCheck fasteners on exposed-fastener panelsReplace cracked tiles; underlayment matters
RepairsEasy and inexpensiveNeeds matching panelsNeeds matching tiles; walking on tile can break it

Prices come from our roof replacement cost guide.

Architectural shingles

The most common Florida reroof. They're the least expensive, easy to repair and available in many colors. Impact-rated (Class 4) shingles cost more and resist hail and debris better; ask your insurer whether they affect your premium before you pay extra. Shingle life in Florida's sun is generally shorter than metal or tile, so compare cost over the years you plan to stay.

Need a contractor for this project?Request a roofing estimate

Metal

Metal roofs come as exposed-fastener panels, such as 5V crimp, which cost less, or standing seam panels with concealed fasteners, which cost more. Metal is light, sheds rain quickly and suits coastal homes, though near salt water you should ask about coatings and fasteners rated for that environment. Standing seam is the premium choice for many coastal buyers.

Tile

Concrete and clay tile define the look of much of South and Southwest Florida. Tile itself is durable, but the underlayment beneath it does much of the waterproofing and has its own lifespan. Tile is heavy, so changing from shingles to tile can require structural review, and broken tiles need matching replacements. Keep spare tiles after installation.

Hurricane performance

Any of these can be the right hurricane roof. The key factors are:

  • a product approved for your home's design pressures, with a Florida product approval or Miami-Dade Notice of Acceptance
  • deck nailing that meets current code
  • a secondary water barrier, which Florida requires at reroof
  • installation exactly as the approval specifies

Those features also show up on a wind mitigation inspection, which insurers use for discounts. Permits and the 25% rule are covered in roof permits.

HOAs and insurance

Many HOAs restrict roof material and color, especially changes from tile to shingles or to metal. Get approval first; see HOA approval. If insurance is paying for the roof, read roof insurance claims before you sign with a roofer.

Frequently asked questions

Which roof is best for hurricanes?

There isn't one answer. Shingles, metal and tile can all be approved for high-wind areas. What matters is that the product is approved for your home's design pressures, the deck is properly attached, a secondary water barrier is installed and the roofer follows the approved installation method.

Does a metal roof make a house hotter?

Not usually. Metal reflects a lot of sunlight, especially in light colors, and many metal products are designed to reduce heat gain. Insulation and attic ventilation matter more for indoor comfort.

Can I switch from shingles to tile?

Often, but tile weighs much more than shingles. Your building department may require an engineer to confirm the framing can carry the load, and your HOA may control the change.

Sources and further reading

We summarize official information in our own words and link to the source. Requirements can change, so confirm details with the source before relying on them. Our editorial standards

Permits & Regulations

Roof permits and the 25% rule

When a Florida roof replacement or repair needs a permit, how the 25% rule and the 2022 change work, reroof code upgrades, inspections and county differences.

Renovation Guides

Wind mitigation inspections explained

What a Florida wind mitigation inspection checks, which upgrades can earn insurance discounts, who can inspect, and how My Safe Florida Home grants work.

Renovation Guides

Roof insurance claims and roofers

How Florida roof insurance rules affect homeowners: claim deadlines, the end of assignment of benefits, roofer solicitation rules and roof age.

Renovation Guides

Getting HOA approval for a project

How HOA architectural approval works for Florida remodels, what state law says about hurricane protection, the 2026 permit change, and tips to avoid delays.